Leggi in italiano
Current Affairs

The factory of falsehood: the price of truth in the age of algorithms (by Michele Muratori)

Disinformation has become a global industry with real human costs — from public health to democracy itself. An analysis by Michele Muratori, Libera's group leader.

The column curated by Michele Muratori, group leader of Libera, continues with its in-depth analysis of current political affairs, the major institutional challenges and the issues of greatest interest to the Republic of San Marino.

********

«Repeat a lie a hundred times, a thousand times, and it becomes truth». This assumption, traditionally attributed to the propaganda machines of the twentieth century, does not merely illustrate the violence of totalitarian persuasion — it defines, with ruthless mathematical precision, the very physiology underpinning our digital information ecosystem.

Where the obsessive frequency of algorithmic exposure has replaced an empirical approach to facts, the truthfulness of a piece of information is no longer measured by its adherence to reality, but by the degree of repetition with which it crosses our screens.

Disinformation has ceased to be a fringe disturbance or a quirk of the web, structuring itself instead as a global, hegemonic industry — a systemic threat to the stability of liberal democracies, extensively documented by leading international research centres.

Chief among those quantifying its structural scale is the landmark study by the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, published in Science by Soroush Vosoughi and co-authors.

By analysing 126,000 news stories spread on Twitter by more than three million users over the course of a decade, the research demonstrated that falsehood travels six times faster than the truth and is 70% more likely to be reshared.

The top 1% of the most viral false content manages to penetrate audiences ranging from one thousand to one hundred thousand people, whereas verified information struggles to exceed a few hundred.

This asymmetry produces a profound erosion of public trust — a phenomenon captured by the Reuters Institute’s Digital News Report, which records that overall trust in news has collapsed to a historic low of around 37%, while 62% of citizens express genuine concern over fake news.

This democratic anxiety is confirmed by a major opinion survey conducted across sixteen nations, in which 87% of respondents directly fear the distorting impact of disinformation on the free exercise of their vote.

This informational short circuit is fuelled by a ruthless economic model. According to estimates from the Global Disinformation Index, websites dedicated to the systematic fabrication of false news generate more than 250 million dollars every year through programmatic and indirect advertising circuits — often unwittingly financed by the budgets of major global brands.

This is the direct legacy of the model that emerged in 2016 in Veles, the Macedonian town documented in investigations by The Guardian, where hundreds of young people ran hundreds of sensationalist sites supporting Donald Trump with the sole aim of monetising traffic through Google AdSense — turning political hoaxes into personal income in an economically depressed area.

When this economy of illusion strikes the living fabric of society, its consequences become physical and lethal.

The 2016 armed intrusion into the Pizzagate pizzeria in Washington, documented in video reports by the Washington Post and driven by a conspiracy narrative incubated on 4chan and Reddit, revealed how porous the boundary between digital fiction and real violence has become.

During the COVID-19 pandemic — defined by the WHO as a genuine infodemic — this distortion took the shape of a parallel health emergency.

A study published in the American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene calculated that in the first three months of 2020 alone, fake remedies caused at least 800 deaths and 5,800 hospitalisations from chemical poisoning.

On the geopolitical stage, the destabilising effect has been engineered on an industrial scale.

Investigations by the Stanford Internet Observatory into the activities of the Internet Research Agency in Saint Petersburg revealed that bots and decoy accounts managed to reach 126 million American citizens during the 2016 presidential election, generating more than thirty million coordinated interactions to exacerbate social divisions.

This systemic interference was also confirmed by British parliamentary reports on Russian influence in the Brexit referendum, carried out through disinformation campaigns and covert influence operations.

In contemporary warfare, disinformation has become the front line of attack.

During the conflict in Ukraine, tracking by the NewsGuard monitoring centre mapped pro-Russian propaganda campaigns aimed at dismantling evidence of war crimes in Bucha, dismissing them as staged theatre performed by actors on the ground.

On the other side, the mythologising of the “Ghost of Kyiv” — the purported lone pilot said to have shot down dozens of enemy aircraft, as analysed by the New York Times — was fuelled by institutional channels and Ukrainian leadership as an emotional tonic to bolster patriotic resistance, before the air force clarified that it was in fact a collective symbol representing the ideal of pilots at the front.

A similar dynamic emerged in October 2023 during the outbreak of the conflict between Israel and Hamas, when the European Digital Media Observatory recorded a 400% surge in false news.

In that dramatic context, disinformation was used to justify the devastation of Gaza.

From unverified reports of violence — later debunked but amplified by political leaders before any confirmation — to the dominant narrative that sought to minimise or obscure the massacre of Palestinian civilians, propaganda exploited suffering to manufacture uncritical consent for military violence.

The result has been to cover up crimes committed against the population of Gaza, turning media manipulation into a silent accomplice of destruction.

What makes this ground so fertile is not technology alone, but the very structure of the human mind.

Cognitive psychology explains that the constant repetition of a claim creates perceptual familiarity, pushing people to accept it as true regardless of the facts. As studies on cognitive laziness show, in emotionally intense contexts individuals switch off analytical thinking in search of immediate gratification.

Today, generative artificial intelligence has dramatically accelerated this scenario, crossing beyond the boundaries of political discourse to overwhelm the economic-financial sphere and interpersonal trust.

The proliferation of deepfakes and the cloning of voices and faces have made falsification instantaneous, cheap, and indistinguishable from reality.

The destructive impact of this technology has moved beyond theory, demonstrating its material lethality in striking cases of social engineering — such as the episode in which an employee of a multinational company in Hong Kong was deceived during a video conference populated entirely by holograms and cloned voices of his superiors, going so far as to authorise a fraudulent transfer of 25 million dollars.

Added to this is the paradox of the “liar’s dividend”, whereby the sheer abundance of fakes allows the powerful to dismiss genuine evidence and investigations by hastily labelling them artificial fabrications.

All of this is fuelled by the rage economy, a system in which platforms reward anger and indignation because they are the most powerful fuels for capturing attention.

In the face of this drift, the countermeasures adopted so far reveal all their limitations.

Debunking a false story once it has already reached millions of people is like trying to gather water with bare hands, while institutional rules struggle against the unstoppable speed of the web.

Reclaiming public space requires equipping society with the critical antibodies needed to dismantle toxic narratives before they strike. At stake is not merely the accuracy of information, but the very resilience of our freedom of choice.

If we fail to build this collective shield, the old adage that «a lie repeated a hundred times, a thousand times, becomes truth» will cease to be a warning about twentieth-century propaganda and become instead a dangerous habit of our present.

La fabbrica del falso – Il prezzo della verità nell’era degli algoritmi (di Michele Muratori)